Feedback

type to search

Comma before etc., part two

Asked by [ Admin ]

It should be pretty clear from "Comma before etc.?" that there should be a comma before etc. when used in a list, but very often I see the opposite. What could be the reason?

Here are examples from Wikipedia and Wiktionary:

  1. ... according to Red Army directive, fuel, equipment, railroad cars etc. were similarly concentrated there. Context, Wikipedia article.

  2. In the analysis of musical form, sections, units etc. that can be defined on the time axis are conventionally designated by letters. Context, Wikipedia article.

  3. Locally, this may refer the leading crop of a region, such as oats in parts of Scotland and Ireland, wheat, barley etc. in England and Wales. Context, Wiktionary article. (Note that there is another error in that sentence, a missing word.)


Update 2: added example from Wiktionary.

Update 1: change now applied at the source for the first two examples.

or Cancel

1 answer

3

donald remero [ Moderator ]

Punctuation, especially the use of commas, is not well understood by most people.
That's about all there is to it.

I don't know what the percentage is of people in the United States, for example, who are even capable of producing true publication-quality prose without assistance of a trained copy editor, but I'll bet that figure is less than one half of one percent -- and probably not even half that.

I think we have also discussed elsewhere the drift in language education away from the strict enforcement of typographical formalities and towards 'whole language,' 'functional grammar,' and argumentation. There must be over two dozen different words for the basic concept. Personally, I am all for it, because I think the evidence is clear that we are actually producing better communicators over all.

But if one does embrace that decision, one also has to accept the consequence of an increased number of people who do not get trained or groomed in the habits of copy editing for conformance to standardized speech. It's just the simple fact that we now have a lot of otherwise very highly educated and articulate people that write a lot, but who have also grown comfortable with outsourcing the finer details of grammar and punctuation to computer programs and when computerized support is not available or inadequate, simply not worrying too much about it.

NN comments
peter mortensen
-
Remero: thanks. I got the reassurence I needed.

or Cancel

Your answer

You need to join iRosetta to complete this action, click here to do so.